Freelance developer, agency or fractional CTO for your MVP?

By

Published

A single pencil, a bundle of pencils and a blue drafting compass point toward the same product

You have an idea, some budget and no technical co-founder. Three kinds of help come up in every conversation: a freelance developer, an agency, and a fractional CTO. They solve different problems, and the wrong one is expensive to undo once the work has started.

I’m a freelance developer, so I’m not neutral. The last section says where I’m the wrong choice.

The short version

  • Freelance developer: best when the scope is clear and small, and you can make product decisions yourself.
  • Agency: best when you need several skills at once, such as design, development, testing and project management, and you want one team to be accountable.
  • Fractional CTO: best when you need technical judgement more than hands on the keyboard.

Freelance developer

A freelancer is good at building a defined thing quickly. One person knows the whole code, you talk to them directly, and there’s less overhead than with a team.

The weak spot is that the same person is often the only one who knows the system. If they get ill or leave, progress stops, and if you can’t judge their work, you won’t know there’s a problem until late. So ask for a repository and hosting in your name, deployments you can see each week, and written notes on how to run the app.

Agency

An agency suits bigger scopes and fixed deadlines, where design, development and testing have to happen together and you want one company to answer for it.

It’s a poor fit for a small project or one whose scope keeps changing. You pay for coordination, and the people in the sales meeting are often not the people building.

I’ve been on the agency side. Through caisy in 2023 I was one of four developers on Constellatio, a learning platform for law students in Germany. Badges, interface work, the learning games and payments moved at the same time, and we reviewed each other’s pull requests. I merged 71 of the 151. One freelancer can’t run four streams of work at once.

Before you sign with an agency, ask for the names of the people who will do the work and what happens to the code and accounts at the end.

Fractional CTO

A fractional CTO works part-time, usually a few days a month, and acts as your technical lead. They’re there for decisions: which technology or vendor to pick, whether to hire an engineer, how to check someone else’s code.

It breaks down when you expect them to build everything. Many fractional CTOs manage the technical side and don’t write the code, so the build still needs someone else.

Before you sign, ask what they will personally do each month, and how they handle a developer who disagrees with them.

How to choose

Ask yourself three questions:

  1. Do I know exactly what to build? If yes, a freelance developer or an agency can price it. If no, start with a short scoping exercise, or a fractional CTO’s advice.
  2. Can I judge the technical work? If not, find someone who can review it, whether that is a fractional CTO, an advisor or a trusted friend with engineering experience.
  3. How much coordination can I take on? A freelancer needs a clear owner on your side. An agency can bring its own project manager, at a price.

Combinations that work

  • Freelancer plus a reviewer. A freelance developer builds, and a technical advisor reviews the plan and the pull requests once or twice a month.
  • Agency for design, freelancer for the product. The agency makes the design system, and a developer builds the product from it.
  • Fractional CTO, then a hire. The CTO shapes the plan and the first hire, and the engineer takes it from there.

Where I fit

I work well on a first product or an existing app when one person can hold the whole picture: building an MVP or taking over an existing app. I’m not the right choice if you need a team of six and a mobile app by the end of the quarter. In that case, look for an agency, and ask them the three questions above.

If you’re not sure which one you need, the contact form is a fine place to describe the situation. I’ll tell you what I would do, even if it isn’t hiring me.

Questions people ask

Is a freelancer cheaper than an agency?

Often the hourly price is lower, but the comparison that matters is total cost for the same scope. An agency includes project management and a team. A freelancer includes you, meaning your time spent coordinating and checking.

When do I need a fractional CTO?

When the questions are about direction, not typing, such as which architecture, which vendor, whether to hire, whether an estimate is fair. A fractional CTO guides decisions. You may still need someone to write the code.

Can I start with a freelancer and move to an agency later?

Yes, if the code and accounts are yours and the choices are common. Plain tools, a clean repository and written notes make any later handover easier.

Build an MVP

One developer from first commit to launch. A small, working first version of your product that real users can try.

Let’s work together.

Tell me what you are building or what needs fixing. You can also email info@ahmed-ghazy.com or find me on LinkedIn (opens in a new tab).

What happens next

  1. 1I read it and reply by email.
  2. 2If it helps, we have a short call.
  3. 3A fixed price for a clear scope, or a monthly one for ongoing work.

I use your details to respond to your enquiry. See the Privacy Notice.